“Back in my religious days if you independently rediscovered an idea already uncovered by some rabbi 400 years ago it was a big deal and great honor, the whole class would celebrate you. The bigger the rabbi the greater the honor.”@hormeze

I think that this is a very healthy approach toward the rediscovery of ideas. Honoring both the lineage of knowledge and the ability to reach a particular conclusion instead of lamenting the fact that we do not get to reap the benefits of being the first to climb a particular hill.

Recognizing the value in the act of having an idea is also a healthy reminder for people afraid of having their ideas stolen: the apple does not fall far from the tree, you will have further good ideas while someone copying your result will have to work backward from that particular conclusion1.


  1. Furthermore, an idea is only a seed. Execution and dissemination are where most of the value is found, without their multiplying effect a great idea is of little value. ↩︎